15 Amazing Weight Watcher Pie Recipes To Make At Home

If your local grocery store doesn’t make a whole lot of Weight Watchers brand dessert, and you want to stick to your Weight Watchers points budget, then there’s all the reason to make your very own Weight Watchers pie in the comfort of your own home.

15 Amazing Weight Watcher Pie Recipes To Make At Home

Besides, baking pie is fun, not to mention tasty. I, for one, love fruit pie, pizza pie and more.

But you can’t just go ahead and make any pie when you’re on the Weight Watchers plan.

Weight Watchers tells you what your points budget each day, having assigned various foods and ingredients points based on their nutritional value compared to the level of calories, saturated fat and sugar content.

However, if you’re careful, you can be on Weight Watchers and still enjoy some mouth watering pie.

And I’ve been scouring the internet to find the best Weight Watcher pie recipes out there, and now I get to share my findings with you. 

So, get those taste buds ready because here’s my shortlist (and the links) for the 15 most amazing Weight Watcher pie recipes on the net!

1. Weight Watchers Key Lime Pie Recipe From Food

Now, there are several Weight Watchers key lime pie recipes on the internet, but this is the one that comes most highly recommended.

After over 90 individual user ratings, the average rating comes out at a very impressive full 5-star rating.

It’s only 3 points per serving, and only requires 5 ingredients, namely a reduced fat graham cracker crust, sugar-free lime gelatin, water, fat-free whipped topping, and key lime yogurt.

To see the recipe in full, simply click on this link.

2. Weight Watchers Double Chocolate Pudding Pie Recipe From Nesting Lane

Who doesn’t love chocolate?! Am I right?

This recipe is super simple to make, and you only need 4 ingredients, including 1% fat milk, a graham cracker prepared pie crust, a delicious sugar-free instant chocolate pudding mix, and fat-free cool whip topping with chocolate shavings to serve.

At just 130 calories per serving, this comes to 5 points on MyWW green plan, or 5 smart points.

To see the recipe in full, simply click on this link.

3. Weight Watchers No-Bake Peanut Butter Pie Recipe From Recipe Diaries

I don’t know about you, but I just love peanut butter! 

The key to making this recipe is to use Jiff Whip Peanut Butter, fat-free cream cheese, and vanilla extract.

On MyWW points, each slice comes to 6 points on the blue, green and purple plans.

I like it served with lite or fat-free cool whip and crushed peanuts on top!

To see the recipe in full, simply click on this link.

4. Weight Watchers Icebox Lemon Pie Recipe From You Brew My Tea

Now, this is what I call a refreshing pie – I just love sharp, citrus flavors! And it’s also deliciously creamy, too.

It’s also super simple to make, and prep time is a mere 15 minutes.

It comes to 4 points plus per serving, or 6 smart points on the WW Freestyle plan, Flex plan, Your way plan, and the Beyond the scale plan.

To see the recipe in full, simply click on this link.

5. Weight Watcher’s Frozen Cappuccino Pie Recipe From Practical Savings

If you’re a coffee lover like me, you will just love this recipe!

It features such yummy ingredients as instant coffee, low-fat cream cheese, fat-free condensed milk, lashings of chocolate syrup, and fat-free whipped topping.

And for additional chocolate flavor, you can use a chocolate flavored ready-made pie crust.

The recipe yields a total of 10 servings, each at just 8 points plus.

To see the recipe in full, simply click on this link.

6. Weight Watchers Crust-less Pumpkin Pie Recipe From Food Meanderings

When Halloween comes around, this dish is a great way of using up fresh pumpkin!

Now, whereas a traditional pumpkin pie would come to 14 WW points, this crustless version comes in at just 3 WW points on most plans.

This is because each of the 8 slices are just 108 calories.

It’s also low-carb and gluten-free, and can be ready to eat in just 45 minutes.

To see the recipe in full, simply click on this link.

7. Weight Watchers Taco Pie Recipe From Slow Cooker Living

Did you think I was going to leave you without a savory pie recipe?

As much as I have a sweet tooth, I also have an appetite for flavorful savory pies, too!

It has all the flavors of a taco, but made into a pie. There’s ground beef, beans, salsa, green onions, tortillas, and tomatoes.

Better yet, it’s only 4 MyWW points on the blue, green, and purple plans.

To see the recipe in full, simply click on this link.

8. Dee Dee’s Weight Watcher’s Strawberry Pie Recipe From Just A Pinch

This dish is just yummy! It’s made with real strawberries, sugar-free jello, and artificial sweetener for the filling, along with crushed graham cracker cookies and margarine for the crust.

The recipe yields 6 servings, each coming in at just under 5 WW points.

A favorite variation of this recipe is to swap the strawberries for peaches, and use orange jello rather than strawberry flavor.

To see the recipe in full, simply click on this link.

9. Weight Watchers Chicken And Mushroom Pie Recipe From Good To Know

Here’s another great savory pie recipe that’s accepted on the Weight Watchers diet!

It’s got healthy protein and veg, in the form of chicken and mushrooms, and comes to only 353 calories per portion.

Simply put the ingredients on your Weight Watchers app to see how many points it comes to on your plan. And it’s ready to eat in just 50 minutes.

To see the recipe in full, simply click on this link.

10. Triple-Chocolate Cream Pie Recipe From Weight Watchers

OMG – this dish is to die for! So rich, indulgent and decadent. Yet it only comes to between 6 and 7 personal points per serving.

The ingredients are all easy to source, and include the likes of chocolate graham crackers, cocoa powder, fat-free half-and-half, and vanilla extract.

I love it served with a sprinkling of pomegranate seeds for color and crunch. Yum!

To see the recipe in full, simply click on this link.

11. Easy Banana Bread “Impossible” Pie Made Lighter Recipe From Simple Nourished Living

This custardy crustless banana bread pie can be enjoyed either hot or cold, and is super simple to make. It’s also a great way to use up leftover overripe bananas.

Each slice comes to 179 calories, and works out at 6 smart points on the green, blue, or purple plans, or 5 points plus on the old plan.

To see the recipe in full, simply click on this link.

12. Apple-Ginger Mini Pies Recipe From Weight Watchers

And now for something a little different. If you’ve never tried apple with crystallized ginger before, boy you’re in for a treat! They pair together perfectly.

This dish also has such flavorful ingredients as brown sugar and fresh lemon juice. And each individual pie has a pretty lattice pattern on the top.

The recipe yields 8 servings, each coming in at between 5 and 9 personal points per serving.

To see the recipe in full, simply click on this link.

13. Light & Easy Low Calorie No Bake Coconut Cream Mounds Bar Pie Recipe From Simple Nourished Living

You know what? I think I love just about anything that tastes like coconut and Mounds candy bars!

This dish is super simple to make, and prep time is a mere 15 minutes. And it’s way lighter than your traditional coconut cream pie, coming in at less than 200 calories a slice.

This recipe works out at 8 smart points on the green, blue, and purple plans, or 5 points plus on the old plan.

To see the recipe in full, simply click on this link.

14. Four-Ingredient Fresh Blueberry Pie Recipe From Weight Watchers

As the recipe title suggests, you only need 4 ingredients to make this pie, namely fresh blueberries, a reduced fat graham cracker pie crust, lite whipped topping, and reduced-sugar mixed berry jam.

It’s super simple to make, and only needs to be left to chill for 2 hours in the refrigerator. It comes to between 6 and 8 personal points per serving.

To see the recipe in full, simply click on this link.

15. Weight Watchers Frozen Yogurt Pie Recipe From Health Beet

Talk about low calories! This pie comes in at a mere 87 calories per serving!

What’s more, you only need 3 ingredients to make it, namely cool whip light, nilla wafers, and Dannon Greek Light and Fit Yogurt.

You can make it in just 3 steps, and it only takes about 30 minutes to set!

To see the recipe in full, simply click on this link.

Wrap Up

I hope you’ve enjoyed browsing through my shortlist. They sound amazing, don’t they! I hope you decide to try one of them out, or maybe more. Bon appétit!

Mark Williams
Latest posts by Mark Williams (see all)