How To Make Canned Cherry Pie Filling Taste Better

The majority of pie fillings from a can are made from cherries that aren’t quite ripe.

Even when they’re at their best, they may be sour. For other manufacturers, it might just be their filling procedure that influences the flavor.

How To Make Canned Cherry Pie Filling Taste Better

The majority of the time, canned pie filling can vary on taste and texture, as do the amounts of acidity. You could come upon a company that has the technique down pat and its cherries are always flawlessly sweet.

When it comes to canned things, you will not always find cherries that are perfectly ripe, which is why you will taste sourness in a lot of pie fillings from a can.

Fortunately, there are various options for preserving your pie filling. You can combine these methods or use them on their own, and either strategy will be beneficial.

Sweeten It

You may sweeten your cherry pie with a simple addition of any white sugar. This is undoubtedly one of the most basic and straightforward methods for sweetening canned filling for a cherry pie.

The simplest way to sweeten canned pie filling is to add brown or white sugar. The amount of sugar is entirely subjective. Begin with 18 cups of sugar (2 tablespoons).

You may also use maple syrup, corn syrup, or honey as a liquid sweetener. If you want something with less sugar, try maple syrup or honey.

However, liquid sweeteners have the potential to thin out the filling. After adding the honey, you may need to thicken the filling.

Add Spices

Adding additional flavor is a quick and easy method to give your cherry pie filling a handmade taste. To add flavor without adding more sugar, use flavor extracts or dried spices.

Begin by adding a teaspoon of almond or vanilla essence. Then experiment with ginger, cinnamon, nutmeg,  or cloves.

Thicken It

Depending on the brand you buy, your pie filling may be severely low in fruit. Use fresh, frozen, or canned fruit to thicken your pie filling.

You could, of course, use cherries, but you could also try something different. Strawberries, blueberries, blackberries, raspberries, apples, and peaches all complement the filling of a cherry pie well.

Cornstarch can also be used to thicken pie filling. To keep your filling from tasting chalky, combine the cornstarch with a pinch of sugar. Alternatively, use a variety of pie thickeners such as flour, arrowroot, or tapioca.

Add Complimentary Fruit

Too much syrup can make your pie unbearably sweet and ruin the texture but adding additional fruit to your canned pie filling can solve this problem and give your dessert a flavor boost.

To improve the syrup-to-fruit ratio and make the filling heartier, add fresh, canned, or frozen fruit to your pre-made filling.

For a unique taste combination, experiment with different fruits. Consider adding blackberries and raspberries to blueberry pie filling for a triple berry pie.

If you want to make your pie more nutritious, bear in mind that frozen fruit keeps more nutritional value than fresh fruit, so use whichever is easiest for you.

If you want to save time, frozen fruit is a good option because it arrives pre-cut and ready to use.

You can also add more cherries to the filling. Whether they be frozen or fresh, sweet or tart, adding more cherries will make the filling firmer and more lively in terms of taste and texture.

How To Make Canned Cherry Pie Filling Taste Better

Add Extracts

Complementary extracts are a fantastic way to add a variety of flavors and fragrances to dull canned pie filling.

Almond extract is the most commonly used extract in cherry pie filling. For a no-bake cherry pie, use 14 to 12 teaspoon per 21 oz. can. 12 to 1 teaspoon almond essence for a baked pie

You may also try adding lemon juice instead, which helps bring out the taste of the cherries and tone down too sweet cherry pie filling.

Begin with 1 tablespoon of juice, taste, and if needed, add some more. Lemon zest is also an excellent addition.

Finally, vanilla extract will work well with the almond and cherry flavors. 12 to 1 teaspoon vanilla extract

Make It Creamy

Adding condensed milk that is sweetened not only sweetens but also makes the cherry pie filling nice and creamy. Please keep in mind that the condensed milk will dull the color of the cherry pie filling.

If you prefer the vibrantly colored red cherry pie filling, try a different sweetener.

Furthermore, sour cream cherry pie is wonderful, especially if you enjoy tart pies. Combine 12 cup sour cream and 2 teaspoons sugar with the canned cherry pie filling. If you believe the canned filling is too sweet, add some sour cream.

Signs That the Canned Cherry Pie Filling Has Expired

It’s possible that your canned cherry pie filling tastes off since it’s over its expiration date.

The most effective way to determine whether canned cherry pie filling is bad is to smell it. Check to see whether the cherries acquire an off-flavor or an unappealing look.

It is also spoiled if molds begin to grow on it. If this is the case, then you need to throw it out.

In addition, discard any canned cherry pie filling that is rusted, severely damaged, leaking, or bulging.

Can Canned Cherry Pie Filling Be Frozen?

Yes, freeze the cherry pie filling in a heavy-duty freezer bag or an airtight container. This increases the shelf life of canned cherry pie filling. As a result, you may freeze it for around two months.

Furthermore, as long as you keep it carefully, it will be safe to use after that time.

In addition, while defrosting canned cherry pie filling in the refrigerator. You can keep it here for up to five days before being used.

If you defrosted the cherry pie filling in cold water or the microwave, however, you should use it straight away.


Canned cherry pie filling may be very convenient, but it is hard to say that it tastes homemade.

Luckily, with just a few dashes of this and that, you will upgrade your watery, tart cherry pie to one that is creamy, sweet, and much more delicious. 

Mark Williams