How To Reheat A Cheesesteak

Everyone loves a classic cheesesteak! Cheesesteak sandwiches, from native Philadelphia, are known for being incredibly indulgent and packed full of flavor and texture. These incredibly satisfying sandwiches make for a perfect lunch, as they are very filling.

How To Reheat A Cheesesteak

The only problem is, because these sandwiches are so filling, it can be easy to find yourself becoming full up very quickly, and you may be left with half of a cheesesteak but no room in your stomach to handle it! 

You don’t want to let the cheesesteak go to waste, but you aren’t sure if such a sandwich can be kept for later and then reheated down the line, which has led you to this very article.

Well, today you have come to the perfect place because today we are going to take a look to find out how you can easily reheat a cheesesteak so that your delicious and morish sandwich does not have to go to waste. 

Read on down below to get started now! 

Can You Reheat A Cheesesteak?

You’ll be very happy to hear that it is definitely possible to reheat a cheesesteak and a healthy option that carries no health risks. Luckily, there are also many ways that you can go about doing this.

Let’s take a look at some of the most popular reheating options that can help to rejuvenate your cheesesteak and give it a whole new lease of life!

The Oven

One of the most popular ways to reheat a cheesesteak is to place it into the oven, which can be a great option if you are planning to reheat numerous cheesesteaks, thanks to the fact that an oven offers a much greater capacity. 

One of the biggest problems with reheating a cheesesteak is the potential that the sub it’s placed in may lose that iconic and delectable crispy texture that contrasts against the soft tenderness of the meat and cheese.

Luckily, using a conventional oven to reheat your cheesesteak is incredibly convenient, because not only does it evenly heat every part of the sandwich, but the warm environment of the oven also causes the sub to crisp up again! 

You should aim to preheat your oven to around 375 degrees Fahrenheit. Once the oven is ready, place each of the cheesesteaks onto your baking tray on top of some aluminum foil, and then place them around the middle shelf of the oven to cook for around 25 minutes. 

Using aluminum foil is beneficial because it helps to ensure that even the lower surface of the cheesesteak is able to heat up substantially while also becoming crispy. This leads to an improved texture overall.

A Toaster

That’s right, if you have a simple toaster, you can easily reheat a cheesesteak! In fact, this option can achieve very similar results as placing your cheesesteak in an oven, but in far less time. However, you will need to have a toaster with enough space for this to work.

A toaster can help to crisp the bread of your cheesesteak up while also providing enough intense heat to reheat all of the ingredients in the sandwich. It can also do this at a much faster rate than a conventional oven, which can make it an incredibly attractive option. 

To avoid the cheesesteaks burning or being otherwise overcooked, you will want to set the toaster to 300 degrees. This temperature is just right as it will allow the ingredient in the sandwich to reheat to a comfortable temperature while also crisping up the bread without risking burning it! 

You should place the cheesesteaks onto a baking sheet, and you can wrap them up in aluminum foil if you wish. This can help them to heat up more evenly. Allow them to cook in the toaster for around 5 minutes before flipping them over and cooking them for a further 5 minutes.

Once the cheesesteaks are cooked, you can simply remove them from the toaster and then allow them to cool down a bit before digging in! 

If you need to heat up multiple cheesesteaks, then you may instead want to opt for using a conventional oven, because toasters have far less capacity, and may only be able to heat up two cheesesteaks at one time.

A Microwave

If you are not able to reheat your cheesesteak in an oven or a toaster, then you can definitely use a microwave, though you should try and save this as a last resort, as it can be tough to achieve the perfect texture, and the bread will not be able to crisp up.

We strongly recommend cooking up the bread separately if possible, by placing it into a toaster oven or your conventional oven, as this will achieve the perfect crispy texture.

You can easily cook the filling of the cheesesteak sandwich in the microwave. Simply place the filling into a dish, and then set the microwave to cook the filling on high heat for around a minute and a half.

If you find that the filling hasn’t cooked fully, you can simply stir it and then put it back into the microwave for an extra 15 seconds. 

If you can’t afford to cook the bread separately, don’t worry, because you can still reheat your cheesesteak in the microwave. Just keep in mind that the bread may become slightly soggy and less appetizing. 

To cook the entire cheesesteak in the microwave, you will want to place the sandwich onto a dish, and take the top of the sandwich off, to allow more even heating. Allow it to cook at medium heat for around a minute and a half! 

An Airfryer

Air Fryers are showing up more and more in kitchens across the country, but you may still be surprised to learn that you can easily reheat a cheesesteak using your own airfryer! 

If you have just one cheesesteak that you want to heat up, then using your airfryer is a great option. Provided your airfryer has a great enough capacity, you can place the cheesesteak directly into it, and allow it to get to work!

All you really need to do is set the airfryer to 300 degrees Fahrenheit, and then allow the cheesesteak to cook for around 4 minutes. 

This method is very effective because air frying causes the bread of the sandwich to regain its crispy outer texture, which makes the sandwich a pleasure to bite into!

However, you should keep in mind that the average airfryer will only have enough space for one sandwich at a time.

How Should You Store A Cheesesteak?

How To Reheat A Cheesesteak

Of course, before you set about reheating a cheesesteak sandwich, you are first going to need to store the sandwich away.

How you choose to store the sandwich before reheating it can directly alter the texture the sandwich will take on after you do reheat it. It will also affect how long the cheesesteak is able to last before being reheated. 

How Long Can You Leave A Cheesesteak Out At Room Temperature?

If you are simply putting half of your cheesesteak down to take a quick break from it before finishing it in less than two hours, then you can leave it on your kitchen counter at room temperature. However, you should not leave it out any longer than this. 

Once the sandwich cools down, it will become a breeding ground for bacteria, making it less safe, and less appetizing to consume. 

How Long Will A Cheesesteak Last In The Refrigerator?

If you want to keep your leftover cheese steak for a little longer, then you should try to place it in the refrigerator as soon as possible. Here, the sandwich will be able to last around a week before you should make sure to reheat it. 

It’s best to place the sandwich into an airtight container to keep the flavor contained! 

Can You Freeze A Cheesesteak?

If you need to keep your cheesesteak around for much longer than a week, you may be wondering if it is possible to freeze the sandwich safely. Luckily, we can say that, yes, it is possible to safely freeze a cheesesteak! 

By placing a cheesesteak into the freezer, you can help it to last up to three months!

However, you should try your best to consume the cheesesteak within this three-month period, as leaving it there past that time could increase the risk of freezer burn, which will cause the cheesesteak to lose its texture and taste! 

You should try to store your cheesesteaks in your freezer wrapped up in aluminum foil, or in an airtight container in order to keep the flavors packed in. 

Frequently Asked Questions

Can You Microwave Philly Cheesesteak?

Absolutely. However, you should keep in mind that microwaving may result in slightly soggy bread.

How Do You Reheat A Steak In The Microwave Without Ruining It?

Luckily, this can be done easily. Place the steak in the microwave for increments of around 30 seconds, on each side. Keep flipping the steak and cooking again for 30 seconds until it is heated up to your satisfaction. 

Is It Bad To Reheat Steak In Microwave?

Though the resulting steak may not have as good a texture as a fully cooked steak, it is totally valid to cook steak in your microwave!

To Finish Up

There you have it! Luckily, reheating a cheesesteak is incredibly easy, because you can simply use a conventional oven you likely already have in your kitchen. Reheating them in the oven also allows you to reheat multiple sandwiches at the same time.

But don’t worry, if you don’t have access to an oven, you can also easily make use of a toaster or a microwave!

Just be sure to store the sandwich carefully before you intend to reheat it so that it can retain its quality.

Mark Williams
Latest posts by Mark Williams (see all)

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *